ขั้นตอนการสร้าง
Twenty questions find any number up to a million
เกี่ยวกับรีเพลย์นี้
A thirty-second data story about binary search, made with FlowPix's motion video tool, which draws the film in code. The brief asks how many yes-or-no questions it takes to find any number from 1 to 1,000,000. It lists the only numbers allowed (500,000 after one question, then 31,250, 977, 31 and 1), forbids any other figure, and supplies a word-for-word voice-over. The requested style is kinetic poster: big numbers as the main words, one hit per figure, only numbers and short labels on screen, with a steady-pulse track under the voice. The brief also says the last shot must be self-contained so it can be changed alone later.
The agent loaded the kinetic-poster skill and, as requested, returned a plan before rendering anything. The plan was a six-row shot table built around a flat red block that loses half its mass on every question, with yellow, black and red colours, a 120 BPM pulse, and a list of things it would not do. After confirmation it wrote and exported a 1920x1080 mp4. Its own check then flagged that the two required wordings in the end card were not showing as specified, and it asked before fixing.
The user instead sent a follow-up to change only the last shot to a 30-question version with new figures. The agent produced version 2 and exported again, and it explained that the automatic check still complained, because the check's fact list was fixed at the first draft. It stated the film itself matched the user's new figures.
The reusable idea is the isolated final shot. Because the brief asked for it up front, the later edit touched one shot and left the other numbers, the voice-over and the music alone.
คำขอ
Make a motion video, 16:9, 30 seconds, with no pictures or photos: a data story that answers "How many yes-or-no questions does it take to find any number from 1 to 1,000,000?" Use only the numbers below, copied exactly. Do not search for, add or estimate any other figure. Each question, "is it higher than the middle?", throws away half of the numbers that are left. At most, 1,000,000 numbers are 500,000 after 1 question, 31,250 after 5 questions, 977 after 10 questions, 31 after 15 questions and 1 after 20 questions. 20 questions are enough because 2 to the power of 20 is 1,048,576, which is more than 1,000,000. In the last shot only, put "20 questions" beside "one at a time: up to 1,000,000 questions", so the gap between the two can be seen at a glance. Keep that last shot self-contained, so that it can be changed on its own later without touching any other shot. I want the kinetic-poster style: the numbers are the big words, one hit per figure, with only the numbers and short labels on screen. Music with a steady pulse, under a voice-over that says exactly this and nothing else: "Think of any number from one to one million. Ask one yes-or-no question: is it higher than the middle? Half the numbers are gone. After five questions, thirty-one thousand, two hundred fifty are left. After ten, at most nine hundred seventy-seven. After fifteen, thirty-one. After twenty, one. Twenty questions are enough, because two to the twentieth power is one million, forty-eight thousand, five hundred seventy-six." Show me the plan first.
สิ่งที่เอเจนต์ทำ
โหลดสกิล “Kinetic poster” — A loud flat-colour poster of huge condensed type and one hero shape per line, morphing and thrown on the beat with hard cuts.
I'll write the plan for this one first — the storyboard comes back before anything is rendered.
Here's the plan — nothing rendered yet.
The one thing on screen throughout: a flat red block that loses half its mass on every yes-or-no question. Its bottom-left corner stays pinned in the same spot from the first frame to the last cut.
The shots
Time On screen Said 0–4 s Yellow field. The red block slams down from above the frame into the right side. On the left, "1,000,000" stamps in black, then the label "numbers". Think of any number from one to one million. 4–10 s A black cut line drops through the block's centre; the right half is thrown off frame. The number hard-swaps to "500,000", label to "1 question". Ask one yes-or-no question: is it higher than the middle? Half the numbers are gone. 10–14 s Four cuts on four beats, each throwing away half: the block ends small at the corner. Five tick bars stamp, one per cut. "31,250" and "5 questions" swap in. After five questions, thirty-one thousand, two hundred fifty are left. 14–18 s Camera pushes in on the pinned corner so the small block fills the frame again; five cuts follow. "977" lands huge, with "at most" above and "10 questions" below. After ten, at most nine hundred seventy-seven. 18–23 s Push in, five faster cuts → "31" with "15 questions". Push in again, five more cuts, the last one snapping the remnant into a small square → "1" with "20 questions".
คำขอเพิ่มเติม 1
Yes, that plan is good. Go ahead and make it, with these numbers only and the voice-over exactly as I wrote it. When it is done, export the mp4 with the music and the voice-over.
สิ่งที่เอเจนต์ทำ
Writing the video now, with exactly your numbers and voice-over.
The video is written — version 1 is in the Motion panel for preview.
It runs the red block through six hard-cut beats while the numbers stamp in at full size, from 1,000,000 down to a single square, and closes on the self-contained end card with "20 questions" beside "one at a time: up to 1,000,000 questions", with the black bar running off frame. Steady 120 BPM pulse underneath, your voice-over exactly as written (29.8 s of it).
Now exporting the mp4 with music and voice-over.
The mp4 is exported at 1920×1080 with the music and voice-over — but the automated check flagged a problem in the last shot: the required wordings "20 questions" and "one at a time: up to 1,000,000 questions" aren't showing as specified there.
Want me to fix that end card so both lines appear exactly as you wrote them, and then export again?
ผลงาน
คำขอเพิ่มเติม 2
Change only the last shot: instead of 1,000,000, put "30 questions" beside "one at a time: up to 1,000,000,000 questions", and under it "2 to the power of 30 is 1,073,741,824" (30 questions are enough for a number up to a billion). Do not touch any other shot, the other numbers, the voice-over or the music. When it is changed, export the mp4 with the music and the voice-over.
สิ่งที่เอเจนต์ทำ
Changing only the last shot, with your new wording and figure.
Version 2 is saved — the last shot now reads "30 questions" beside "one at a time: up to 1,000,000,000 questions", with "2 to the power of 30 is 1,073,741,824" underneath; every other shot, the numbers, voice-over and music are untouched.
One note: the automatic check flags those two new figures as not being in the original fact list — that's only because the list was fixed when the video was first written. They're exactly the numbers you gave, so nothing is wrong. Exporting now.
The mp4 is exported with the music and the voice-over, at 1920×1080 — the last shot now shows "30 questions" beside "one at a time: up to 1,000,000,000 questions", with "2 to the power of 30 is 1,073,741,824" under it.
Two things the automatic check still names, both expected: it asks for the old end-card wording ("20 questions" / "one at a time: up to 1,000,000 questions") that you just replaced, and it doesn't recognise 30 or 1,073,741,824 because they weren't in the original fact list. Those are your own figures, so the film itself is as you asked.